The Warehouse, 47-49 Cowleaze Road, Kingston Upon Thames, KT2 6DZ
+44 (0)208 541 3434

Authenticity is king on social, but agility will be crucial as big changes loom

Performance Communications Author Image Performance Communications | November 9, 2026

Ella Rebbitt looks at the rise of TikTok, how it’s changed the dynamics of the influencer game, and whether another big shift is around the corner.

When you think of influencer brand collaborations, you probably think of Instagram, right?

Take it back to the noughties, when bloggers were busy building followings and communities around fashion, food, lifestyle and more. Brands quickly took note of their unique, authentic voices and the relationships they had built with their audiences – offering an alternative to traditional advertising.

Then came Instagram.

Throughout the 2010s, the platform grew alongside the influencer-brand marketing boom. Beautifully curated feeds, inspirational content and rapidly growing follower counts gave the average Joe the potential to become a celebrity – and a valuable brand ambassador. What started with aesthetic images has evolved into creators inspiring and even shaping entire campaigns.

More recently, TikTok changed the influencing game again.

With its For You page capable of shooting micro-creators into almost instant stardom, creators could reach millions of people within hours. If content resonated, the algorithm could massively boost it, regardless of the creator’s follower count.

This resulted in a less polished, more spontaneous style of content that leans even further into authenticity.

Influencers are no longer simply another channel for paid promotion. Of course, they can still play that role, but they can also launch a product, generate genuine conversation or explain what a product does in a way that doesn’t feel like an advert.

And brands can find incredibly niche creators. They might not have millions of followers, but the audiences they do have can be highly engaged and genuinely interested in what they’re talking about.

This is not to say TikTok has overtaken Instagram. Instagram still has a well-established place in influencer marketing, but the type of content that works on each platform can be very different.

TikTok has the advantage when it comes to discovery and the potential for virality. Instagram remains a strong platform for established creators and long-term brand partnerships, particularly among higher-profile influencers.

The influencer landscape is now firmly multi-platform. Creators often have a presence across several channels, but audiences behave differently on each one.

Perhaps the biggest shift, however, is that followers aren’t the be-all and end-all.

For example, if you’re a carmaker launching a new car in the UK, you might want a petrolhead who can walk viewers through the pros and cons of the vehicle, keeping it authentic and relevant to an audience that genuinely cares about the details.

That doesn’t mean a lifestyle creator wouldn’t make a great brand ambassador. Their strength just lies elsewhere. Put them behind the wheel on a road trip to a relevant location and you’ve got a story that fits naturally into their content, rather than forcing them to explain the technical specifications of a car their audience might not care about.

For brands, a smaller creator with a highly engaged, relevant audience can be far more valuable than someone with millions of followers but little genuine connection to the subject.

The platforms may keep changing, but the fundamentals of influencer PR haven’t.

Change is coming

With how things stand currently, the social media landscape might be about to undergo a big change. Meta is being pressured over the way its platforms are designed, especially when it comes to children and young people. It has agreed to introduce measures like default time limits for teens, muted notifications and hidden likes, following the $18bn settlement over claims that Facebook and Instagram harm children. In California, a separate trial could go even further, with features like infinite scrolling, autoplay and algorithm-dominated feeds potentially being removed altogether.

If this is where social media is heading, it could have a big effect on influencer marketing as we know it. Less reliance on algorithm-driven feeds. Reduced engagement from younger audiences. Greater restrictions around how content is consumed. These could all change what makes a creator valuable to a brand. Having said that, this only proves the point that, as they evolve, brands must continue to utilise multiple social media platforms and react to them accordingly. The value lies in the relationship between a creator and their audience, and that can travel with them across platforms, wherever or whenever the next big thing comes along.

OEMs should not only rely on collaborations but prioritise their own social channels, too. BMW is a great example of this, and one to watch on TikTok. It keeps things professional but is quick to jump on trends. Recently, we’ve seen BMW hop on trends like “your camera roll if you were dating a girl with a BMW”, “five things that are worth the money”, “when someone calls me fast but that’s the least interesting thing about me”, “what will haunt me on a cold January morning”, “this and yapping”, and “kinda chic to…”

One trend we’ve seen a lot of car brands jump on is ASMR. A few accounts have created their own versions using trending audio. A favourite is Mazda US, who’ve clearly done their research – right down to including the nail tapping on the car, which is pure ASMR-creator.

And as we know, authenticity is what matters.

Credit: Image by Thomas Ulrich from Pixabay.


Related stories.

Is Reddit worth the effort for AI visibility?

Reddit is the only forum that really registers (72% of forum citations over the last month) for AI tools, but it’s still a small slice: only about 6% of AI answers cite it. So, what pulls it in? Three question themes lead: practicality, reliability and electric. Together, they account for 37% of all Reddit citations. […]

Clubs risk driving away fans through underinvestment in their stadium experience

Ten years ago, our Future of the Sports Fan report highlighted how fans had increasingly high expectations of the live sporting experience. Today, Arsenal’s plans to modernise the Emirates Stadium shows just how seriously some clubs are taking that challenge a decade on. Despite being only 20 years old, the stadium is set for upgrades […]

How Automotive Awards Are Shaping AI Visibility

According to Engine Room, the RAC editorial pages are the fifth-most cited domain in AI search with the likes of ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AIO and Perplexity behind CarWow, What Car?, Auto Express and YouTube. This year saw the launch of the RAC New Car Awards. So how did this impact its AI visibility? RAC announced […]

AI Search Is the New Top of the Funnel for Automotive Brands

AI search is now the top of the funnel for car sales. Rather than a page of links and magazines off the shelves, car buyers are asking ChatGPT. And those clicking through from AI are four times more likely to convert. It means understanding how you’re appearing on AI platforms, such as ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and […]

What Makes AI Recommend One Car Brand Over Another?

We know that online search is changing as car buyers switch to AI over traditional search engines when researching their next vehicle. So what makes ChatGPT and other LLMs surface one car brand over another? The answer starts with consistency. A consistent brand voice across every digital touchpoint – your own digital content, social media channels […]

AI search success: Don’t be fooled into thinking it’s all about your brand website

Andy Francis explains how LLMs are the ultimate dinner party hosts when it comes to understanding the scrap for AI recommendations Measuring success on how many times your brand website is cited is NOT the goal in the age of AI-assisted search. Let me explain. Picture a dinner party. The LLM is taking your place […]

How electric vehicles hold the key to balancing Europe’s energy grid

Harnessing the European car parc to help provide a stable energy grid sounds like the work of science fiction, but Lindsey Reaney explains it could be closer to reality than you think One of the big challenges for electricity grids running off periodic generation sources like renewables is the issue of intermittency: what happens when […]

SEO vs GEO: Why PR Is Becoming More Important in the Age of AI

SEO vs GEO: what communications teams need to know. The gold standard of online automotive content has long been page one visibility, driven by high-quality articles laden with keywords and search terms. In short, SEO (or Search Engine Optimisation). The equation was simple. Rank higher on Google, get more clicks, increase organic site traffic, generate […]

Be Bold.

It’s time to come off the fence:


Message us