The Warehouse, 47-49 Cowleaze Road, Kingston Upon Thames, KT2 6DZ
+44 (0)208 541 3434

Website version

A red card for SPOTY?

Performance Communications Author Image Performance Communications | November 27, 2013

Nominees for the BBC’s Sports Personality of the Year 2013 have been announced and yet again, the list causes a lot of chatter. Who should and who shouldn’t be included, what sports are not represented* and where are all the women? ‘Sexist’, ‘sportist’ and ‘elitist’ are all words that have been associated with this year’s list.

SPOTY has a history of controversy. The 2011 list received a lot of criticism for having no female nominees. 2012 was a great year for women in sport – the BBC reported that 36% of Team GB medals and 47% of ParalympicsGB medals won at London 2012 came from women so a list that included 42% of females (five women from a total of 12 people) seems to me to be a fair representation.

However since the heady days of London 2012, everyone seems to have moved on, including the media and the sponsors. The Women’s Sport and Fitness Foundation states that only 5% of sports media coverage is devoted to women’s sport and just 0.5% of commercial investment goes to women only sport (men get 62.1%).

On the flipside, men play more sport than women. The Department for Culture, Media and Sport’s Taking Part survey from 2012 shows that although more women than ever are playing sport (8.7 million women are playing sport or taking part in recreational walking or cycling for 30 minutes a week compared to 7.7 million in 2005 / 06), women still had lower levels of participation than men (39.7% compared with 49.9% for men).

[quote align=”center” color=”#111111″]I don’t believe women should be on the list for the sake of it. I don’t agree with quotas to get more females in the boardroom. I do believe females should get where they are on merit. By being excellent at what they do.[/quote]

Nevertheless the issue is that women in sport play at top levels and yet are not treated equally in terms of media coverage, funding and sponsorship. All of these aspects play a role but as a communications professional, I believe the media has a huge role to play in helping to raise awareness of women in sport. I understand that more people watch men playing football / golf / cricket / etc. than women playing any of those sports. However it’s a vicious circle. If the media don’t show women in sport, it’s hard for young women to feel inspired to take part in sport, it’s hard to become a fan and support women in that sport and it’s hard to get funding to do that sport.

Some progress is being made. Stylist magazine has been running a ‘fair game’ campaign since early 2012 and it found that for every 53 articles written about sporting men, there is one about a woman. The Sunday Times runs a ‘Sportswomen of the Year’ awards with recently announced sponsor Sky Sports. The report from the BBC website on the 2013 nominees goes to great lengths to promote the female angle: Hannah Cockcroft and Christine Ohuruogu are two of the three athletes first mentioned, it refers to the fact Clare Balding and Gabby Logan will present the awards alongside Gary Lineker, it mentions how Baroness Grey-Thompson, Dame Kelly Holmes and Liz Nicholl from UK Sport were on the judging panel and with impressive editorial independence, it gives a nod to the criticism of the all-male list in 2011. But is this enough? Where is Laura Trott, Non Stanford or Becky James?

In the past ten years, two women have won the Sports Personality of the Year award: Dame Kelly Holmes in 2004 and Zara Phillips in 2006. In 60 years, 13 women have won it. As amazing as Hannah and Christine are, I can’t see them winning it this year. So come on British media. Give women a sporting chance.

Nicola

* Too many other sports to mention but motorsport (Sam Lowe, Tai Woffinden, Tom Sykes), squash (Nick Matthew) and boxing (Carl Froch) seem to feature highly in people’s criticism of the list.


Related stories.

Performance Communications Transitions To Employee Ownership

Performance Communications, a leading provider of specialist communications services to the Automotive, Sport and Technology industries is delighted to announce that it has transitioned to employee ownership via an Employee Ownership Trust (EOT). The move secures the agency’s long-term independence and will provide its employees with both a greater level of involvement and a share […]

Cricket at the Olympics, it’s just not cricket!

Let’s set the record straight, I don’t like cricket, I love it* but cricket at the 2028 Olympics, is that really necessary? The IOC has announced the five new sports that will be included in the 2028 Los Angeles Olympic Games. Funnily enough some of the new sports that will appeal to a Northern American […]

Top 5 Sports Documentaries – The Power of Sports Documentaries

It seems that recently a new pro sports documentary appears on an almost daily basis, 24-7 viewing if you need to get away from the family over Christmas! While the docs undoubtedly provide the streaming channels with engaging content to draw subscriptions and drive revenue, should sporting associations or teams always give the green light […]

Unveiling Threads: Exploring the Disruptive Factors and Success Behind the New Social Media App

In a rapidly evolving social media landscape, new platforms emerge, seeking to disrupt the status quo and capture users’ attention. Can Threads go the distance though?

What are the pros and cons of an EV Motorcycle (According to ChatGPT)

What happens when you ask AI tool ChatGPT to create a blog article for you? Well, judge for yourself…   Electric-powered motorcycles are becoming an increasingly popular option for riders who are looking for an environmentally friendly and low-maintenance mode of transportation. In this article, we’ll take a look at some of the pros and […]

Our favourite World Cup PR campaigns

The biggest stage in football is just days away as all attention turns to Qatar for what is set to be a competition like no other. With over 3.5 billion people watching the 2018 edition in Russia, including 1.12 billion for the final match alone, the World Cup provides brands with an unrivalled platform for […]

Its time to place human stories at the heart of the advanced air mobility market

If you ask me to imagine the future, the first thing my mind often flicks to is the opening scene of Futurama – with flying cars and robotaxis gliding over giant skyscrapers. This always felt like an incredibly distant vision but autonomous flying machines are here today and they are already doing a lot of […]

The UEFA Women’s Euros 2022

Now the crescendo of excitement of England’s Euros triumph has subsided, Nicola McKelvey takes a deeper look at the huge growth of the women’s Euros and the England team in an article that quantifies and compares the positive momentum of the UEFA Women’s Euros 2022 to previous events. Introduction It’s widely believed that major tournaments […]

Be Bold.

It’s time to come off the fence:


Message us